This questionnaire is useful for attorneys comparing and contrasting two competing offers, as well as attorneys considering the prospect of remaining at their current firm. While there are undoubtedly many questions to ask yourself when considering an offer (and we will discuss these topics at length below), I believe it is most important to focus on four major questions:
1. Do you feel a positive gut instinct about this firm and the offer?
2. Are you excited about the opportunity?
3. Do you feel that this firm has offered you an opportunity that is better than your current situation?
4. Can you envision a long-term relationship with this firm, or does the opportunity at this firm get you closer to your ultimate goal?
If the answers to the above questions are affirmative, then it is likely that the move will be a positive one! But there are many other factors that will influence your decision. Spend some time carefully asking yourself the questions below and filling out the worksheet at the conclusion of the questionnaire.
OFFER ANALYSIS QUESTIONNAIRE
Personality Considerations
Does the firm generally share your beliefs/attitude regarding the practice of law?
Are you comfortable around the associates and partner with whom you'll be working?
Do you feel a sense of collegial camaraderie at the firm?
Have you talked with other associates who have worked for the partner you will be assigned to? What did they think of the partner? What is the partner's reputation as a boss?
Can you see yourself genuinely fitting in at the firm?
Does the firm share your work ethic?
Have you considered the dress code of the firm? Does the attire match your personality? (Or can you live with the dress code?)
Has there been a great deal of turnover at the firm in recent years? This can point to a potentially hostile environment.
Have you done your homework on the firm?
Check all available research outlets:
Have you examined the bonus structure at the firm?
Have you looked at the profits per partner for the firm? And have you examined any differences between tiered partnership tracks?
Have you considered the frequency with which attorneys in your section make partner at the firm?
Will there be quite a few associates at your level that will be up for partnership at the same time? Will there ultimately be several associates competing for one partnership spot?
Have you talked with associates at your level who are already practicing with the firm? (Be discreet, however, and do not make those at the firm feel they are under too much scrutiny.)
Have you read any recent articles published about the firm (in The American Lawyer, for example)?
Do the dollars make sense?
Is this firm offering you a pay raise, is the salary equivalent to what you are paid now, or will you receive a pay decrease?
Will you be "slotted" at an appropriate level for your graduation year? Will you have to take a step back in terms of the length of time it will take you to make partner? (This could be a good thing if you need more time to hone your skills/adapt to a new location/grow your book of business. But it can be a major negative for some.)
Is the firm paying market salary for its size and reputation?
If the firm offers lower salaries, does it make up for it with lower billable-hour requirements, more hands-on opportunities, or better quality of life?
Will the salary help you achieve your personal financial goals (paying off law school loans, buying a house, etc.)?
Again, examine the cost of living if you are changing locations. Do not get too hung up on the overall numbers; instead, determine how far a dollar goes in the new location you are considering.
Is the firm itself financially stable?
Location, location, location
Is this offer in a city where you can see yourself living for a length of time?
Is it important to your significant other to be in this region or location?
Do you have friends and family in the region?
Is the economy of the region healthy? Are businesses thriving and growing in the region? Will there be sufficient business/future clients to sustain the office of the firm?
Is the office a satellite office? Is there enough work to sustain the office's growth?
Is the future growth of this particular office a firm-wide goal?
Do lawyers in this particular office make partner?
Examine the cost of living in the city where the office is located. (See cgi.money.cnn.com/tools/costofliving/costofliving.html.)
Does the city's lifestyle match your interests and activities?
Will the climate affect you? Are you averse to warm climates? Do you tend to be miserable in cold climates?
Diversity considerations
Does the firm have a strong diversity program?
Does the firm not only attract diverse talent but also retain diverse talent?
Are diverse attorneys at the firm making partner?
Are there strong women's initiatives at the firm?
Are there a lot of women partners?
Is there a supportive work environment for parents?
Does the firm have a strong reputation for being GLBT friendly? (See www.hrc.org/placestowork.)
Practice Area Considerations
Will new learning opportunities be available to you?
Will the opportunity expand the breadth of your experience?
Will you have the opportunity to work in your desired practice area?
Will you be working with well-regarded attorneys in your particular field?
Will there be opportunities for you to explore new and interesting practice areas in addition to your own? Is this important to you?
Will there be an opportunity in the future for you to change your practice area? Or will there be an opportunity to work in a new area of law that is attractive to you?
Will there be possible in-house opportunities in the future?
Do corporations like to hire from this particular law firm?
Will there be opportunities to receive the rigorous law firm training that companies so value?
Will the prestige of the firm open doors for you in the corporate environment at a later stage?
Firm size
Is the size of the firm important to you?
Are you more comfortable in a large firm or in a small firm?
Is it important to you that your firm have a national presence? An international presence? A regional presence?
How many people work in the office you are considering? Is that a plus or a minus?
How important is it to you to have the resources that large firms provide?
Are you more comfortable in a large firm or in a small firm
Is it important to you to have a large support staff?
Prestige
Is the firm ranked on the Am Law 100? The Am Law 200?
Is the firm recognized in your region?
Is the firm recognized by Chambers & Partners?
Does the firm have large Fortune 100 clients? Fortune 500 clients? Sophisticated clients?
Environment
Do you like the firm's offices? Does the quality of the offices matter to you?
Do you like the location of the office in which you will be working?
Are the offices convenient to your home? If not, will this be a large sacrifice?
Quality of life
Have you examined any quality-of-life considerations at the firm?
Have you assessed whether the firm is on any quality-of-life "lists" (whether good or bad)?
Have you examined associate satisfaction rankings?
PROFESSIONAL GOALS WORKSHEET
In two years, I see myself ____________________________________________.
In five years, I see myself ____________________________________________.
In 10 years, I see myself _____________________________________________.
In 20 years, I see myself _____________________________________________.
My preferred firm is of small/medium/large (circle one) size.
My preferred firm is in this region in the short term: _____________________
My preferred firm is in this region in the long term: _____________________
I want my working environment to be: _________________________________.
I want my practice to encompass: _____________________________________.
Please rank in order of importance to you (be honest and realistic with yourself!):
_____I want to specialize in a particular area.
_____I want to change my practice area.
_____I want high-profile clients/cases/deals.
_____I want to work for a very well-regarded partner.
_____I want to have great opportunities for mentorship and training.
_____I want to have access to numerous resources.
_____I want to have prestigious firms on my resume.
_____I want to have ample opportunities to go in-house in the future.
_____I want to make partner (and work at a place where this is possible).
_____I want to work for an international firm.
_____I want lower billable hours.
_____I want to find an alternative career.
_____I want opportunities for direct client contact.
_____I want to be in the courtroom on a regular basis.
_____I want to work in a different region or city.
_____I want a higher level of compensation.
_____I want significant opportunities for pro bono work.
_____I want to find a firm where I can stay for a long time.
_____I want a supportive, nurturing environment.
_____I want an opportunity to work abroad.
_____I want job security at a stable firm.
_____I want to work with collegial individuals.
_____I want a nice mixture of work and quality of life.
_____I want leaner staffing of cases/deals (more responsibility).
_____I want to work in a large office.
_____I want to start my own firm.
_____I want to develop my own clients.
_____I want to work in a firm that values diversity.
_____I want to work in a firm that has good opportunities for women.
_____Other:
Which five or six factors did you rank the highest? These are the most important points to keep in mind while you consider your offer. Does the opportunity match your future goals and desires?
4. Can you envision a long-term relationship with this firm, or does the opportunity at this firm get you closer to your ultimate goal?
If the answers to the above questions are affirmative, then it is likely that the move will be a positive one! But there are many other factors that will influence your decision. Spend some time carefully asking yourself the questions below and filling out the worksheet at the conclusion of the questionnaire.
OFFER ANALYSIS QUESTIONNAIRE
Personality Considerations
Does the firm generally share your beliefs/attitude regarding the practice of law?
Are you comfortable around the associates and partner with whom you'll be working?
Do you feel a sense of collegial camaraderie at the firm?
Have you talked with other associates who have worked for the partner you will be assigned to? What did they think of the partner? What is the partner's reputation as a boss?
Can you see yourself genuinely fitting in at the firm?
Does the firm share your work ethic?
Have you considered the dress code of the firm? Does the attire match your personality? (Or can you live with the dress code?)
Has there been a great deal of turnover at the firm in recent years? This can point to a potentially hostile environment.
Have you done your homework on the firm?
Check all available research outlets:
- Avery Index
- Chambers & Partners
- Vault
- American Lawyer
Have you examined the bonus structure at the firm?
Have you looked at the profits per partner for the firm? And have you examined any differences between tiered partnership tracks?
Have you considered the frequency with which attorneys in your section make partner at the firm?
Will there be quite a few associates at your level that will be up for partnership at the same time? Will there ultimately be several associates competing for one partnership spot?
Have you talked with associates at your level who are already practicing with the firm? (Be discreet, however, and do not make those at the firm feel they are under too much scrutiny.)
Have you read any recent articles published about the firm (in The American Lawyer, for example)?
Do the dollars make sense?
Is this firm offering you a pay raise, is the salary equivalent to what you are paid now, or will you receive a pay decrease?
Will you be "slotted" at an appropriate level for your graduation year? Will you have to take a step back in terms of the length of time it will take you to make partner? (This could be a good thing if you need more time to hone your skills/adapt to a new location/grow your book of business. But it can be a major negative for some.)
Is the firm paying market salary for its size and reputation?
If the firm offers lower salaries, does it make up for it with lower billable-hour requirements, more hands-on opportunities, or better quality of life?
Will the salary help you achieve your personal financial goals (paying off law school loans, buying a house, etc.)?
Again, examine the cost of living if you are changing locations. Do not get too hung up on the overall numbers; instead, determine how far a dollar goes in the new location you are considering.
Is the firm itself financially stable?
Location, location, location
Is this offer in a city where you can see yourself living for a length of time?
Is it important to your significant other to be in this region or location?
Do you have friends and family in the region?
Is the economy of the region healthy? Are businesses thriving and growing in the region? Will there be sufficient business/future clients to sustain the office of the firm?
Is the office a satellite office? Is there enough work to sustain the office's growth?
Is the future growth of this particular office a firm-wide goal?
Do lawyers in this particular office make partner?
Examine the cost of living in the city where the office is located. (See cgi.money.cnn.com/tools/costofliving/costofliving.html.)
Does the city's lifestyle match your interests and activities?
Will the climate affect you? Are you averse to warm climates? Do you tend to be miserable in cold climates?
Diversity considerations
Does the firm have a strong diversity program?
Does the firm not only attract diverse talent but also retain diverse talent?
Are diverse attorneys at the firm making partner?
Are there strong women's initiatives at the firm?
Are there a lot of women partners?
Is there a supportive work environment for parents?
Does the firm have a strong reputation for being GLBT friendly? (See www.hrc.org/placestowork.)
Practice Area Considerations
Will new learning opportunities be available to you?
Will the opportunity expand the breadth of your experience?
Will you have the opportunity to work in your desired practice area?
Will you be working with well-regarded attorneys in your particular field?
Will there be opportunities for you to explore new and interesting practice areas in addition to your own? Is this important to you?
Will there be an opportunity in the future for you to change your practice area? Or will there be an opportunity to work in a new area of law that is attractive to you?
Will there be possible in-house opportunities in the future?
Do corporations like to hire from this particular law firm?
Will there be opportunities to receive the rigorous law firm training that companies so value?
Will the prestige of the firm open doors for you in the corporate environment at a later stage?
Firm size
Is the size of the firm important to you?
Are you more comfortable in a large firm or in a small firm?
Is it important to you that your firm have a national presence? An international presence? A regional presence?
How many people work in the office you are considering? Is that a plus or a minus?
How important is it to you to have the resources that large firms provide?
Are you more comfortable in a large firm or in a small firm
Is it important to you to have a large support staff?
Prestige
Is the firm ranked on the Am Law 100? The Am Law 200?
Is the firm recognized in your region?
Is the firm recognized by Chambers & Partners?
Does the firm have large Fortune 100 clients? Fortune 500 clients? Sophisticated clients?
Environment
Do you like the firm's offices? Does the quality of the offices matter to you?
Do you like the location of the office in which you will be working?
Are the offices convenient to your home? If not, will this be a large sacrifice?
Quality of life
Have you examined any quality-of-life considerations at the firm?
Have you assessed whether the firm is on any quality-of-life "lists" (whether good or bad)?
Have you examined associate satisfaction rankings?
PROFESSIONAL GOALS WORKSHEET
In two years, I see myself ____________________________________________.
In five years, I see myself ____________________________________________.
In 10 years, I see myself _____________________________________________.
In 20 years, I see myself _____________________________________________.
My preferred firm is of small/medium/large (circle one) size.
My preferred firm is in this region in the short term: _____________________
My preferred firm is in this region in the long term: _____________________
I want my working environment to be: _________________________________.
I want my practice to encompass: _____________________________________.
Please rank in order of importance to you (be honest and realistic with yourself!):
_____I want to specialize in a particular area.
_____I want to change my practice area.
_____I want high-profile clients/cases/deals.
_____I want to work for a very well-regarded partner.
_____I want to have great opportunities for mentorship and training.
_____I want to have access to numerous resources.
_____I want to have prestigious firms on my resume.
_____I want to have ample opportunities to go in-house in the future.
_____I want to make partner (and work at a place where this is possible).
_____I want to work for an international firm.
_____I want lower billable hours.
_____I want to find an alternative career.
_____I want opportunities for direct client contact.
_____I want to be in the courtroom on a regular basis.
_____I want to work in a different region or city.
_____I want a higher level of compensation.
_____I want significant opportunities for pro bono work.
_____I want to find a firm where I can stay for a long time.
_____I want a supportive, nurturing environment.
_____I want an opportunity to work abroad.
_____I want job security at a stable firm.
_____I want to work with collegial individuals.
_____I want a nice mixture of work and quality of life.
_____I want leaner staffing of cases/deals (more responsibility).
_____I want to work in a large office.
_____I want to start my own firm.
_____I want to develop my own clients.
_____I want to work in a firm that values diversity.
_____I want to work in a firm that has good opportunities for women.
_____Other:
Which five or six factors did you rank the highest? These are the most important points to keep in mind while you consider your offer. Does the opportunity match your future goals and desires?
