Dangers of Negotiating Your Offer in a Down Market | BCGSearch.com

Dangers of Negotiating Your Offer in a Down Market

640

Print/Download PDF

Font Size

Rate this article

84 Reviews Average: 5 out of 5

''Go on, take the money and run''
-Steve Miller Band
In this current lateral market, unless you are planning on bringing a self-sustaining book of business to your new firm, be careful when negotiating your offer. The following story, which I heard from a friend at another recruiting firm in the mid-West, drives this point home very well.
 
Dangers of Negotiating Your Offer in a Down Market

An Unexpected Negotiation Outcome

My friend was working with a counsel-level candidate who went through the interview process at a large firm. This candidate did not have a particularly large book of business, but specialized in an area that is very in-demand. This candidate received an interview with a firm that had been looking - for a long time - for somebody with this particular skill set. While the candidate's book of business was on the low end, the skill set was in demand, which made the lower book of business less of an immediate issue.


Fast-forward a few weeks, and interviews went very well. Great synergies, talking about mutual clients, and the platform really seems to be ideal for the candidate. Likewise, the candidate's skill set seems ideal for the firm. While the portable business is still lower than expected, this seems like a very good fit and the potential to develop business is clear.

Around this time, the firm starts the due diligence process and checking the financials. Despite the low book of business, the other elements seem to be enough to get the green light for an offer. Fast-forward a few weeks. References are checked, they clear with a breeze, and all looks good.

The firm makes an offer, but it was as Counsel, not Partner. The candidate really liked the firm, but was hoping for a partner title (non-equity or contract partner was fine, so long as he has the Partner title).

At this same time, the candidate received an offer from a second firm, and this offer was with a non-equity title. At this point, it seemed reasonable to go back to the first firm to see if they could change the title to contract partner in order to make the offer more attractive.

The candidate decided to ask the first firm if they would consider the partner title. At this point, the relevant partners (who were strongly in favor of hiring this person) agreed that this made sense and sent the proposal for the revised offer to the hiring committee. It seemed very likely that the first firm would match the other offer, as they did not want to lose him. This is when things took a turn.

The revised offer caught the attention of a few partners that previously had not made any objections to this candidate. Now - in the context of a counteroffer, where there seemed to be competition with other firms - there was much closer scrutiny from a contingent of partners in the firm. While common wisdom would dictate that competing offers would cause the first firm to desire the candidate even more (under the theory of ''that which may be lost becomes more desired''), this did not quite turn out as planned. Given the economic crisis and focus on saving costs, some partners became concerned about hiring this candidate, even though the offer had previously been extended.

Discussions (heated) among the hiring committee ensued and questions (accusations) such as, ''Why are we hiring this person right now in this economy?'' started to spear. Before long, a power struggle developed: those in favor of hiring versus those against.

What happened next was unexpected. After deliberation, the firm decided that, upon further reflection and in light of the economy, the original offer probably should not have been extended. The firm apologized profusely, but told this candidate that the entire offer was rescinded. Off the table. Caput. The candidate was understandably taken aback and very upset.

Had the candidate simply accepted the original offer, this outcome would have likely never occurred. By negotiating, the candidate gave the firm an opportunity to reevaluate the offer and, in this case, the offer was taken away. Was this an unfortunate - though understandable - gamble by the candidate? Or maybe it was fate's way of intervening and the final outcome was best for everybody involved.

I understand that this story is quite extreme, but it is not an isolated incident in this market. As we have seen, a growing number of firms have rescinded offers to summer associates or first-year associates due to the economy. This happens much less frequently on the lateral side, but it does happen.

My Home-Selling Experience - Learning the Hard Way

Speaking on a larger level, I think one of the most difficult challenges for candidates right now is truly accepting that times have changed. Since the market is in an uncertain place, previous reference points on what's a ''good'' offer or a ''bad'' offer are no longer accurate. The value is what the market will offer.

I learned this lesson the hard way when I was selling my house this past summer (of '08). My realtor told me the market value was $625,000, based on recent sales. At the same time I was about to put our house on the market, one of my neighbors - who has the exact same model - walked by and mentioned that she was planning to sell hers as well. I asked how much, and she said, ''$674,000.'' I was planning on selling ours for $634,500, but when I heard that she was listing it for $674,000, I thought we were underselling. Despite our realtor's assessment (based on recent sales) I told her, ''I want to list ours for $646,500.'' She asked why, and I told her about the home up the street that was listed at $674,000.''

She replied, ''Dan, listing prices are fantasies . . . closed sales are reality.'' Since I tend to be stubborn, I didn't listen. I was greedy and wanted the price I think I should have been able to get in late-2007. I was in denial about the harsh reality of the real estate market, and simply didn't want to acknowledge that times changed. I thought that I was being smart by pricing it higher, and leaving some room to come down.

We listed it at $646,000 and our first offer came in a few weeks later at $615,000. I was insulted. Thinking back, we should have given the buyer a hug and a kiss. But we countered with $630,000 and shortly thereafter Lehman Brothers fell apart and the economic crisis began. The buyer got cold feet and walked away. This was similar to what happened to the candidate mentioned above.

Without going into any more detail here, we finally sold the house a number of months later for $590,000. I am firmly convinced that if we listed the house at $625,000, as originally advised, we would have sold it for about $30,000 more, as the house would not have ''lingered'' on the market as long as it did. My problem was that I didn't want to face the reality of the new real estate market, and I had outdated definitions of what my house was really worth. It was the summer of 2008 and I was still mentally stuck in 2007.

How is this relevant to you? Don't get hung up on what you (or your ego) think you should be worth now. The market value right now is what a firm (or firms) will pay for your experience. Nothing more, nothing less.

Conclusion - Go On, Take the Money and Run
In closing, with the exception of candidates who have self-sustaining books of business that they can bring to their new firm, it's important to understand that negotiations can backfire much more easily right now. Like the initial buyers of my house, law firms can get cold feet very easily. This is not a time to be greedy, and the phrase ''penny wise and pound foolish'' is more relevant than ever in this context. Anybody who knows me will tell you that I am not the type of person who advocates just rolling over and taking the first offer due to fear of losing it. Nobody wants to settle and feel like they are leaving money or opportunity on the table. That being said, if you get a reasonably good offer, and it's the only one you have (or at the firm you really want), heed my advice: Go on, take the money and run. I wish I did.

About Harrison Barnes

Harrison Barnes is a prominent figure in the legal placement industry, known for his expertise in attorney placements and his extensive knowledge of the legal profession.

With over 25 years of experience, he has established himself as a leading voice in the field and has helped thousands of lawyers and law students find their ideal career paths.

Barnes is a former federal law clerk and associate at Quinn Emanuel and a graduate of the University of Chicago College and the University of Virginia Law School. He was a Rhodes Scholar Finalist at the University of Chicago and a member of the University of Virginia Law Review. Early in his legal career, he enrolled in Stanford Business School but dropped out because he missed legal recruiting too much.

Barnes' approach to the legal industry is rooted in his commitment to helping lawyers achieve their full potential. He believes that the key to success in the legal profession is to be proactive, persistent, and disciplined in one's approach to work and life. He encourages lawyers to take ownership of their careers and to focus on developing their skills and expertise in a way that aligns with their passions and interests.

One of how Barnes provides support to lawyers is through his writing. On his blog, HarrisonBarnes.com, and BCGSearch.com, he regularly shares his insights and advice on a range of topics related to the legal profession. Through his writing, he aims to empower lawyers to control their careers and make informed decisions about their professional development.

One of Barnes's fundamental philosophies in his writing is the importance of networking. He believes that networking is a critical component of career success and that it is essential for lawyers to establish relationships with others in their field. He encourages lawyers to attend events, join organizations, and connect with others in the legal community to build their professional networks.

Another central theme in Barnes' writing is the importance of personal and professional development. He believes that lawyers should continuously strive to improve themselves and develop their skills to succeed in their careers. He encourages lawyers to pursue ongoing education and training actively, read widely, and seek new opportunities for growth and development.

In addition to his work in the legal industry, Barnes is also a fitness and lifestyle enthusiast. He sees fitness and wellness as integral to his personal and professional development and encourages others to adopt a similar mindset. He starts his day at 4:00 am and dedicates several daily hours to running, weightlifting, and pursuing spiritual disciplines.

Finally, Barnes is a strong advocate for community service and giving back. He volunteers for the University of Chicago, where he is the former area chair of Los Angeles for the University of Chicago Admissions Office. He also serves as the President of the Young Presidents Organization's Century City Los Angeles Chapter, where he works to support and connect young business leaders.

In conclusion, Harrison Barnes is a visionary legal industry leader committed to helping lawyers achieve their full potential. Through his work at BCG Attorney Search, writing, and community involvement, he empowers lawyers to take control of their careers, develop their skills continuously, and lead fulfilling and successful lives. His philosophy of being proactive, persistent, and disciplined, combined with his focus on personal and professional development, makes him a valuable resource for anyone looking to succeed in the legal profession.


About BCG Attorney Search

BCG Attorney Search matches attorneys and law firms with unparalleled expertise and drive, while achieving results. Known globally for its success in locating and placing attorneys in law firms of all sizes, BCG Attorney Search has placed thousands of attorneys in law firms in thousands of different law firms around the country. Unlike other legal placement firms, BCG Attorney Search brings massive resources of over 150 employees to its placement efforts locating positions and opportunities its competitors simply cannot. Every legal recruiter at BCG Attorney Search is a former successful attorney who attended a top law school, worked in top law firms and brought massive drive and commitment to their work. BCG Attorney Search legal recruiters take your legal career seriously and understand attorneys. For more information, please visit www.BCGSearch.com.

Harrison Barnes does a weekly free webinar with live Q&A for attorneys and law students each Wednesday at 10:00 am PST. You can attend anonymously and ask questions about your career, this article, or any other legal career-related topics. You can sign up for the weekly webinar here: Register on Zoom

Harrison also does a weekly free webinar with live Q&A for law firms, companies, and others who hire attorneys each Wednesday at 10:00 am PST. You can sign up for the weekly webinar here: Register on Zoom

You can browse a list of past webinars here: Webinar Replays

You can also listen to Harrison Barnes Podcasts here: Attorney Career Advice Podcasts

You can also read Harrison Barnes' articles and books here: Harrison's Perspectives


Harrison Barnes is the legal profession's mentor and may be the only person in your legal career who will tell you why you are not reaching your full potential and what you really need to do to grow as an attorney--regardless of how much it hurts. If you prefer truth to stagnation, growth to comfort, and actionable ideas instead of fluffy concepts, you and Harrison will get along just fine. If, however, you want to stay where you are, talk about your past successes, and feel comfortable, Harrison is not for you.

Truly great mentors are like parents, doctors, therapists, spiritual figures, and others because in order to help you they need to expose you to pain and expose your weaknesses. But suppose you act on the advice and pain created by a mentor. In that case, you will become better: a better attorney, better employees, a better boss, know where you are going, and appreciate where you have been--you will hopefully also become a happier and better person. As you learn from Harrison, he hopes he will become your mentor.

To read more career and life advice articles visit Harrison's personal blog.


Article Categories

AGREE/DISAGREE? SHARE COMMENTS ANONYMOUSLY! We Want to Hear Your Thoughts! Tell Us What You Think!!

Related Articles

We've changed thousands of lives over the past 20 years, and yours could be next.

When you use BCG Attorney Search you will get an unfair advantage because you will use the best legal placement company in the world for finding permanent law firm positions.