Viability of Switching Practice Areas for Attorneys: A Detailed Exploration

The difficulties attorneys face when trying to switch practice areas are numerous. First and foremost is the issue of expertise. An attorney with years of experience in litigation, for example, may be seen as a "first-year associate" if they try to move into a transactional area like corporate or real estate. This is because the skills required for these different practice areas can be vastly different, and firms are unlikely to invest the time and resources needed to train an attorney in a completely new area.

Moreover, the marketability of an attorney is often tied to their experience in a specific practice area. Law firms, particularly those hiring laterally, are looking for candidates who can immediately add value in their existing practice. This makes it difficult for attorneys to switch practice areas, especially when trying to do so through traditional recruiting methods.

 

Possible Paths to Making the Switch

Despite these challenges, there are potential paths for attorneys who are determined to switch practice areas:

1. Transitioning Within the Same Firm: Some attorneys have successfully switched practice areas within their existing firms. This usually requires the attorney to have built a strong reputation in their current area, making them valuable enough that the firm is willing to accommodate their request. In some cases, attorneys may start by taking on work in the new area alongside their current duties, gradually making the transition.
2. Moving to a Smaller Firm: Attorneys may find it easier to switch practice areas by moving to a smaller firm. Smaller firms tend to require their attorneys to be more generalist, handling a variety of matters rather than specializing in one narrow area. This can provide an opportunity for attorneys to gain experience in a new practice area that would be difficult to enter in a larger firm.
3. Switching Markets: Moving to a smaller legal market can also increase the chances of successfully switching practice areas. In smaller markets, there is often less competition for positions, and firms may be more willing to hire attorneys with less experience in the desired practice area, especially if the attorney has strong overall credentials.
4. Targeting In-Demand Practice Areas: Another strategy is to focus on practice areas that are in high demand. For example, when the economy is strong, corporate law is often in high demand, and firms may be more open to hiring attorneys from other practice areas. However, even in such cases, the transition is challenging, and success is not guaranteed.
5. Shifting to Consumer-Facing Firms: Attorneys who want to switch practice areas might also consider moving to firms that cater to individuals rather than large corporations. For example, a litigator might transition into trusts and estates or consumer bankruptcy, where the skills required are somewhat different, and firms may be more flexible in their hiring criteria. These positions, however, often come with lower compensation compared to corporate-focused firms.

 

Success Stories: Exceptions, Not the Rule

While the challenges are significant, there are examples of attorneys who have successfully switched practice areas. One such example is a patent attorney who transitioned into environmental law after persistent efforts and a willingness to move markets—from Silicon Valley to Sacramento. Another is a litigator who successfully moved into corporate law within his existing firm after extensive networking and proving his value.

These stories, however, are exceptions rather than the rule. Success in switching practice areas often requires a combination of factors: a willingness to relocate, a flexible attitude towards compensation, strong networking skills, and a bit of luck.
 

---

See Related Articles:

• Comprehensive Overview of Key Legal Practice Areas
• How Attorneys Can Switch Legal Practice Areas: The Definitive Guide to Switching Legal Practice Areas for Attorneys
• So You Want to Switch Practice Groups?

---

Final Thoughts: Considerations Before Making the Switch

Before attempting to switch practice areas, it is important for attorneys to carefully consider their motivations and the realities of the legal market. Switching practice areas is not impossible, but it is difficult, and the road is fraught with challenges. Attorneys should weigh their options, perhaps exploring opportunities within their current firms or considering moves to smaller firms or markets where their chances of success might be higher.

Ultimately, the decision to switch practice areas should be made with a clear understanding of the potential risks and rewards. For some, the challenge may be worth it, leading to a more fulfilling career in a practice area that better aligns with their interests and goals. For others, the difficulties might outweigh the benefits, leading them to either find ways to make their current practice area more fulfilling or to consider alternative career paths outside of traditional law practice.

---